First Pass(over) at Matzoh Ball Soup

A friend of mine just sent me a text message, “chag sameach.” She flew up to San Francisco to be with her family for their Seder dinner tonight to kick off the eight-day celebration of Jewish freedom from slavery, Passover. She got me right in the midst of my second self-lesson in Jewish culture and history through food. First lesson was Thursday, with coconut macaroons, and today, it’s matzoh ball soup.

I’m not a stranger to matzoh, though it’s been a long time since I’ve eaten it. Many of my friends in elementary and middle schools were Jewish. Oh yes, I definitely went to my fair share of bar and bat mitzvahs, and was pea green with envy that my friends had such elaborate celebrations. After school snacks at their houses were often sheets of matzoh spread with peanut butter or what I liked, just plain butter. Matzoh just looked like giant saltines to me. Matzoh ball soup is also not totally new to me, as it’s often served in a medicinal role for me on Sunday afternoons when I stumble into the local deli to nurse a wicked hangover. Incidentally, matzoh ball soup is also unofficially known as the Jewish penicillin.

When I asked my friend’s mother about how to make matzoh balls, she told me to just buy the Manischewitz matzoh ball soup mix and follow the instructions on the back of the box. Make matzoh ball soup from a box?!? For some reason, I had a vision in my head. Three generations of Jewish women in a kitchen all day, slowly simmering a whole chicken and vegetables on the stove, grinding matzoh into meal, making the matzoh ball dough, sitting around the table telling stories and shaping matzoh balls by hand for hours. Um, I guess not. I went to the market, and though there are matzoh ball soup mixes that have seasonings already added to the matzoh meal, I couldn’t bring myself to buy it. I bought the plain matzoh meal instead.

shaped by hand, and chilled for an hour

The recipe for matzoh balls is essentially the same across the board, with only ratios differing slightly of matzoh meal, water, some sort of fat, eggs, and salt. There are variations in additional seasonings, as Joy of Cooking recommends adding herbs like fennel or dill, as well as dried ginger and curry powder. An article about the Battle of the Matzoh Balls at does a good job of comparing several recipes. Instead of the sometimes suggested seltzer water to add fluffiness, I stuck with plain (Brita-filtered, of course) water. However, I did beat the two egg whites separately into stiff peaks before folding into the egg yolks, salt, and parsley. No oil, butter, or schmaltz (chicken fat) for me. After adding the matzoh meal, it didn’t look like it would make very much. *shrugs* It’s my first time so better to be safe with a few than sorry with a whole big mess of what could potentially turn out to be *ick* The hour they chilled in the fridge was just enough time for making the soup part. Most of the pictures I’ve seen of matzoh ball soup are a simple clear broth with a few matzoh balls, but the soups I’ve actually eaten have always had vegetables and chicken, so that’s to what I’m accustomed. Carrots, celery, onion, and I couldn’t resist adding several cloves of garlic. I’m sure that’s not traditional, but *eh* at least I didn’t add hot peppers!

Matzoh balls are no more difficult than meatballs to form, though I did end up with a lovely pair of thin matzoh meal gloves that muted my claps of mini-joy when I stood back and looked proudly at the 10 tiny perfect, parsley-speckled ping pong matzoh balls on my chopping block. I softly slipped them into simmering salted water one by one, of course careful not to splash, but more careful because these were my little babies.

I didn’t know what to do with myself for the 30 minutes of cooking time. I paced, rather took the two and a half steps it takes to get from one end to the other of my tiny little apartment kitchen, trying to find things to do – scraping the matzoh ball dough off my hands, washing the far-too-many dishes and utensils I had overzealously used for only 10 little matzoh balls, seasoning, tasting, the reseasoning the vegetable soup. You see, I had to do anything and everything but lift the lid on the pot, for it is an uninterrupted, covered bath that keeps matzoh balls fluffy and tender, yet without falling apart. Well, the lids to my pots are glass (genius, whoever designed glass lids), so at least I was able to peek in on them every few minutes like a young mother peeps over the side of the crib to gaze upon her sleeping newborn.

how they’ve grown after 30 minutes!

As the kitchen timer ticked downward, no joke, I had my hand poised on the lid. 4…3…2…1. It beeped at 0, and I yanked open the lid, practically giving myself a facial with the huge pouf of steam. Amazingly, over the half hour, my little angels, originally ¾ of an inch, had swollen to almost two inches! *sigh* They grow up so fast, don’t they? Admiration lasted all of about 5 seconds before I fished the first one out of the water, and unable to hold back, I took my first steaming-so-careful bite right there from the slotted spoon. My little babies were good.

a good, solid, square (round?) meal

It was a somewhat cold and gray day (yes, 65 degrees is quite chilly for almost-May in LA), so the steaming hot broth of the vegetable soup was perfect. We were able to slice through the soft, tender, yes, quite fluffy, outside of the matzoh balls with the side of a spoon, yet the centers were denser and chewier, enough to feel like something substantial and
solid enough to be lunch. Added to the vegetable soup, matzoh balls make a meal.

So far so good on my first two lessons in Jewish food and culture. Do I have it in me to try gefilte fish next?!

Blog Widget by LinkWithin

{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Rachael April 24, 2005 at 2:29 pm

I LOVE your ambition! Gorgeous matzoh balls. But as far as Maneschewitz is concerned…try it just once, for a compare and contrast, you’ll be amazed. ALSO – two little tips – Check out the book Jewish Cooking In America (it’s amazing) and if you get a chance, take a field trip to the Elan market on Pico (west of Robertson), it’s terrifically eye opening. (And CHEAP!) Now, when you want a nice kugel recipe, give me a call.


2 MEalCentric April 24, 2005 at 3:34 pm

Your passion cracks me up! I have a hard time picturing a Korean girl cooking jewish food. Great pictures btw ;)


3 MEalCentric April 24, 2005 at 3:34 pm

Your passion cracks me up! I have a hard time picturing a Korean girl cooking jewish food. Great pictures btw ;)


4 Eve April 24, 2005 at 9:38 pm

Awww, I love you sweetie! Getting in touch with your Jewish side! Now I know why you didn’t text message me back-you were up to your elbows in matzah balls!!!
Chag Sameach!!


5 Jessica April 27, 2005 at 12:09 am

Wow, color me impressed! Look at those perfectly even, and impeccably shaped beauties! Even if I got many compliments on my batch of matzoh ball soup this Passover, your discipline puts my lazy approach to shame. I usually shape them as I toss into the water. There are plenty variations one can do, but I usually just tweak the basic recipe on the matzoh meal container. And BTW, the mix is the same stuff, just with some seasoning tossed in.


6 Helen (AugustusGloop) May 1, 2005 at 7:14 am

Hey, I’m vaguely intrigued by Jewish food too! I was only grilling someone recently about matzoh balls recently (I’ve never had them but remain fascinated by them).

These look great. Thanks for sharing–and your babies are a credit to supportive (but not suffocating) parenting =)


7 Anonymous September 8, 2006 at 4:49 pm

I am just about to embark on my first foray into making matzo ball soup. I stumbled on your blog while looking up matzo meal. Thanks for the enlightening description. Believe it or not, it encourages me. I LOVE matzo balls but live in Cheyenne, WYOMING where it’s practically unheard of! Thank goodness I can at least buy matzo meal at the grocery store! Wish me luck!!!


8 sarah September 8, 2006 at 4:58 pm

anonymous: best of luck to you. to be quite honest, to make good matzo ball soup is NOT difficult. mine was pretty good.

but to make GREAT matzo ball soup…well, i gotta find myself a jewish grandmama ;)


9 Anonymous September 11, 2006 at 4:57 pm

I made them and they turned out GREAT! Everyone raved and they seemed to be just the right size and consistency. It was my first but definitely not my last time making these. I brought leftovers for lunch today while at work. YUMMY! Your description of what to do definitely helped me a LOT! THANKS again!


10 sarah September 11, 2006 at 5:01 pm

anonymous: omg! that is awesome! i’m so glad that they came out so well!!! :)

and you don’t have to be a shy stranger ;)


11 Stephen January 29, 2007 at 8:47 pm

Where’s the recipe?


12 Stephen January 29, 2007 at 8:47 pm

Where’s the recipe?


Cancel reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: